Columbus Urban Core Preservation Brief

A Sacred Map in Peril

As Bishop Earl K. Fernandes deconsecrates the historic 1898 Gothic sanctuary of St. John the Evangelist in Old Oaks—anchoring decades of Black Catholic ministry and civil rights outreach—the Catholic Diocese of Columbus moves concurrently to raze its downtown administrative chancery for surface parking and clear Franklinton’s 1913 Holy Family School.

Old Oaks • Downtown • Franklinton Three Urban Sites Tracked September 2026 Filings & Landmarks Vulnerability
Location Overview • Three Urban Nodes

A Coordinated Contraction Across Columbus’s Core

In the historic neighborhoods flanking downtown Columbus, the Catholic Diocese of Columbus is reshaping its physical presence through sweeping parish mergers, deconsecrations, and municipal demolition applications.

While public attention has centered on the vulnerable status of St. John the Evangelist in the Near East Side’s Old Oaks neighborhood, diocesan filings submitted in September 2026 reveal that the church’s uncertain fate is part of a broader urban real-estate retrenchment stretching west through Downtown and across the Scioto River into Franklinton.

Old Oaks (East) St. John Church Deconsecrated Jan 2026
Downtown (Center) 197 E. Gay St Raze for Surface Parking
Franklinton (West) Holy Family School Demolition Filed Sept 2026
Campus Architecture • William P. Ginther & David Riebel

An Architectural Anchor in Vitrified Dark Brick

Rising at South Ohio Avenue and Newton Street, St. John the Evangelist stands as one of Columbus’s most intact ecclesiastical Gothic complexes. Designed by noted ecclesiastical architect William P. Ginther and consecrated on September 24, 1899, the church was built using heavy, rock-faced vitrified brick.

Its twin copper-clad towers soar 132 feet above Victorian residential streets, flanking a dramatic stone rose window and triple gabled portal entries.

  • 136 ft × 54 ft Nave: Designed with an original capacity of 800 worshipers beneath rib-vaulted deep blue ceilings.
  • 32-Foot Altar Reredos: Intricately carved Gothic woodwork centering the crucified Christ and sacred statuary.
  • 1905 Parish School: Built by David Riebel, the revered first architect of Columbus City Schools who designed more than 40 educational landmarks.
  • 1899 Rectory & 1950 Convent: Flanking brick quarters housing clergy and the Sisters of St. Francis of Penance and Christian Charity.
Liturgical & Civic Crucible • 1897 to Present

From German Immigrant Fortress to Black Catholic Beacon

Founded in 1897 under Bishop John Watterson and Fr. Simon Weisinger to serve German immigrants near the Pontifical College Josephinum, the parish underwent profound transformation as post-war suburban white flight and the physical carving of Interstate 70 reshaped the Near East Side.

Rather than closing its doors, the parish merged with neighboring Holy Rosary in May 1979 to form the Community of Holy Rosary-St. John. Within a decade, the parish was approximately 70% Black, pioneering a vibrant gospel liturgy that doubled Sunday Mass attendance.

1971 Parish establishes the St. John Community Center, launching food distribution, emergency support, and neighborhood adult literacy programs.
1979 Holy Rosary merges into St. John; the parish becomes the East Side's primary anchor of Black Catholic identity.
1980s Gospel choir introduced to Catholic liturgy; parish hosts Rev. George Stallings Jr. (1986 revival) and prominent MLK Jr. Day commemorative masses.
2024–26 Bishop Fernandes merges parish into St. Dominic (Jan 2024); final Mass celebrated May 12, 2024. Church formally deconsecrated on Jan 21, 2026.

Even after liturgies ceased, the St. John school continues to serve the community, housing a vital food pantry and a free medical clinic operated in partnership with the Sovereign Military Order of Malta.

Downtown Commission Filing • September 2026

197 E. Gay St: Five Stories Slated for Surface Parking

In September 2026, the Roman Catholic Diocese of Columbus submitted plans to the City of Columbus Planning Division seeking a Certificate of Appropriateness to demolish its five-story chancery at 197 E. Gay Street, a masonry building constructed in 1908 that the church has owned since the 1960s.

Sitting immediately behind St. Joseph Cathedral, the building has housed diocesan administration, Catholic Social Services, and the Our Lady of Guadalupe Center. The explicit scope in the city filing: building demolition “and conversion to surface parking.”

Regulatory Friction at the Downtown Commission

City building officials noted that while an unsafe order followed a partial brick wall collapse in January 2026, the diocese had pulled no demolition permits with Building and Zoning Services. The Downtown Commission historically rejects razing intact buildings solely to expand surface parking lots without an approved replacement structure.

Cross-City Comparison • Franklinton & Old Oaks

57 S. Grubb & The Looming Fate of St. John

Simultaneously in September 2026, demolition applications were submitted for the historic Holy Family School at 57 S. Grubb Street in Franklinton. Built in 1913 in the Romanesque Revival style, the building served as a dry haven of refuge when the Great Flood submerged Franklinton, later housing the Jubilee Museum and a soup kitchen feeding 300 vulnerable residents each day.

This parallel filing across the Scioto River underscores why Columbus Landmarks designated St. John Catholic Church as one of the city’s Most Endangered Sites.

Property Built Historic / Community Role Current Status (2026)
St. John the Evangelist 648 S. Ohio Ave (Old Oaks) 1898 William P. Ginther High Gothic landmark; David Riebel 1905 school; crucible of Black Catholic liturgy and Malta medical outreach. Deconsecrated
Most Endangered Site; millions cited in repairs
Diocesan Chancery 197 E. Gay St (Downtown) 1908 5-story masonry building behind St. Joseph Cathedral; diocesan offices, Catholic Social Services & Guadalupe Center. Demolition Filed
Application filed to convert site to surface parking
Holy Family School 57 S. Grubb St (Franklinton) 1913 Romanesque Revival sanctuary during 1913 Great Flood; Jubilee Museum; soup kitchen serving 300 daily. Demolition Filed
Filed Sept 2026; Columbus Landmarks Endangered

While St. John’s inclusion in the Old Oaks Historic District on the National Register of Historic Places provides significant architectural prestige, federal listing does not legally shield a building from demolition if an owner demonstrates financial hardship.

As Near East Side community groups, former parishioners, and preservationists urge adaptive reuse, the diocese’s concurrent actions in Downtown and Franklinton signal that Columbus’s sacred masonry heritage stands at an existential crossroads.